About CA Care

In obedience to God's will and counting on His mercies and blessings, and driven by the desire to care for one another, we seek to provide help, direction and relief to those who suffer from cancer.

I Can’t Believe That By Just Taking Tamoxifen, The Cancer Will Not Come Back

Part 1: I Can’t Believe That By Just Taking Tamoxifen, The Cancer Will Not Come Back Part 2. The Cost of Diagnostic Procedures and Mastectomy in Hong Kong Part 3: Suffered Menstrual Problems for 34 Years. CA Care Therapy Helped Her

Olive (not her real name) is a 46-year-old lady who works in a hospital in Hong Kong.

  • About 2 years ago, she had pain in her left breast. She did a mammogram and ultrasound. However, the doctor said there was nothing wrong with her – no cancer at that time.
  • Vaccination history: Olive had 3 shots of Covid-19 vaccination.
  1. First dose of BioNTech vaccine on 9 April 2021.
  2. Second dose of BioNTech vaccine on 14 May 2021.
  3. Third dose of BioNTech vaccine on 3 March 2022.

About 6 months after her third dose of vaccine, in September 2022, the pain in her left breast came back again. Due to the heavy work load in the office and also her past experience, Olive ignored this problem.

A few months later, Olive felt a mass in her left breast. It prompted her to go for a mammogram and ultrasound. This was later followed by a biopsy . They found cancer in her left breast.

Oliver underwent a total mastectomy. The cancer was just a Grade 1, ER +ve, PR +ve and HER2 -ve with no lymph node involvement.

There was no need for chemotherapy but Olive was started on tamoxifen on 18 October 2022..

On 25 October 2022, I received this email.

Dear Dr. Chris,
I am Olive from Hong Kong and I just had my left breast mastectomy on 5 Oct, 2022. I would like to make an appointment to see you and seek your advice and help in treating my cancer. I can fly to Malaysia to see you with my husband when you are available.
I was recommended by my ex-colleague, Ms. SE, to see you. She had breast cancer and received your treatment about 20 years ago. At that time, she had bone and liver metastases, but after following your advice and treatment, her problems were resolved.
Though my cancer is just Grade I with no lymph node involvement, I think I must seek your treatment and advice otherwise I am just waiting for a recurrence.

Ms. SE told me about you, Dr. Chris. I then visited your website and read your articles. I think you are the right person to help me. I must try my best to see you.

I still have to work, but I can take leave if Dr. Chris can arrange an appointment for me on Thursday or Friday. I can fly from Hong Kong and then fly back. I can fly to Malaysia again for follow up.

Is it possible to work on this? Attached please find all my medical reports for your reference and information. Thank you so much and I’m looking forward to your reply. Have a nice day!

Hello Olive, there is NO need for you to fly and see me. Since the Covid-19 outbreak, I adopted a different way of helping patients. We can talk via whatsapp video – so it is just like talking to me in person. I have done this with many patients from Indonesia and it works out very well. So I can talk to you via whatrsapp too.
After our talk and after studying the medical reports, I shall prescribe the herbs and send them to you by express post. Then when you get the herbs we can talk again on how to prepare the tea, etc. If you like this idea, we can do that in the next few days. Please let me know. Chris.

Dear Dr. Chris,
Thank you so much for your email reply! Yes, if you can talk with me through whatsapp video, it would be even more convenient for me. I am so glad and thank you so much!
Yes, I know SE personally, she is my ex colleague. She is also the one who took the mammogram for me. When she saw the mammogram of my left breast, she was so worried and felt sorry for me. But I said this to her, “Everyone needs to go through the process of being sick and death. I will accept it.”

However, she told me, ‘It is true, but we still have to fight for our life. You have your little son, your mum and your husband.”

Then I suddenly remembered that my dad, after his stroke, went to the beach and swam every day, no matter if it was summer or winter. My mum had her heart surgery and hip surgery. In her eighties, she is still struggling – getting up by herself, cooking by herself and going to market by herself. She said if she doesn’t exercise and work, she is just waiting for death. Everyone is fighting for life and so do I.

Yes, Dr. Chris, please let me know when you are available for the online consultation. May I invite my husband to join the meeting too? Because I want him to understand my treatment more.

Dr. Chris, you have saved SE. She told me she is now helping her daughter to take care of her grandchildren. She needs to tell them bedtime stories before their sleep. Thank you and I’m looking forward to your reply. Have a nice day!

  1. Who is SE? She was our breast cancer patient. She had undergone all medical treatments but failed. Then she wrote to us for help in August 2002. That was 20 years ago. We are indeed happy to know what SE is still doing so well in Hong Kong after following our therapy.


2. Our privilege to be able to help Olive. After reading Olive’s email, I am convinced that Olive is going to be a “good” patient. And we are more than willing to help Olive regain her health again. She showed such a positive attitude in wanting to make her life better. And she believes that what she is going to do is going to be good for her. No, she does not write “shopping” for an instant magic cure. She is willing to work for her healing.

Olive wrote:

  • I can’t believe that by just taking tamoxifen, the cancer will not come back. I have read some of your articles, you mentioned that we have to change our lifestyle and food and also our way of thinking. The idea enlightens me and I know Dr. Chris, you can help me.
  • I have the courage that I can follow your diet. I am lucky that I don’t like sweet at all. I like vegetables. I don’t like meat even before I have my cancer except fish … I just have to make sure that I got enough nutrients from the veggie diet. I have to eat more varieties of fruits, vegetables and beans … and keep the oil as little as I can when cooking. Some said breast cancer patient cannot eat soy bean because it has hormones but some said yes because it can protect breast cancer patient, Dr Chris, may I know your recommendations? (My reply: It is okay to take soy bean!).
  • The only problem for me is stress. When I go to work, it seems that I have to throw myself into a battle every minute – lots of email, lots of documents to read, and different people would come to me and ask for benefit from the department …and I have to manage people too. I work from 9 a.m. to 9 p.m.
  • I would try my best to focus on my health and my loved ones.
  • One of my friends introduced me to join the Qigong group this coming Saturday.
  • If I can meet with Dr. Chris, I think I am lucky enough and seems everything is arranged by God.
    Yes, that is the way to go Olive. Take care of yourself and heal yourself. Let us walk this healing journey together

Healing of Skin Cancer – Squamous Cell Carcinoma

Adek is my cousin sister. Sometime in March 2020 she had a small blister with a white spot on her left eyebrow. When pressed pus mixed with blood oozed out of the blister. It caused a sharp pain once in a while. The lesion did not go away. Two months later, Adek went to consult a doctor at the university hospital.

On 20 May 2020, Adek underwent an out-patient surgery that lasted about two hours to remove the lump. Histopathology report confirmed it was a squamous cell carcinoma, a type of skin cancer.

After surgery, the doctor prescribed some medications and suggested that Adek undergo radiotherapy. She refused the treatment but took the medicine.

Initially after the surgery, Adek’s forehead  started to swell and it took about 10 months before the swelling subsided. The scar started to heal but once in a while she felt itchy. Apart from that her recovery was smooth.

During this recovery period, Adek suffered the following:

1. Cough. This came on and off and this was followed by a copious discharge of white-greenish phlem. The dischage of phlegm came after taking food.

2. A few days in a week she had difficulty breathing.

3.She felt breathless after walking some distance.

Adek went back to her doctor regualarly for check-up.

To monitor her progress a high-dose contrast-enhanced computed tomography (CECT) was performed on 14 July 2021. The results were as follow:

1. Brain: There is irregular enhancing subcutaneous soft tissue thickening at the left frontal region.

2. Abdomen / Pelvis: Small non-enhancing hypodense lesion at upper pole of right kidney, upper and interpole of left kidney likely represent cysts.

3. Bone. No suspicious lytic or sclerotic lesion.

4. Neck/Thorax:  Multiple lung nodules seen bilaterally as below:

  • Small subpleural nodule at apical segment of right upper lobe (Image: 41,43).
  • Small subpleural nodule (Image 64, 71) and lung nodule at anterior segment of right upper lobe (Image 46, 68, 69, 84).
  • Lung nodule at medial segment of right middle lobe measuring 0.4 cm x 0.3 cm (Image 142).
  • Small subpleural nodule at superior segment of right lower lobe (Image 152, 171).
  • The largest nodule at right horizontal fissure measuring 0.5 cm x 0.3 cm (Image 113).
  • Small subpleural nodule (Image 60, 85) and lung nodule at anterior segment of left upper lobe (Image 72).
  • The largest nodule at inferior segment measuring 0.5 cm x 0.3 cm (Image 155).
  • Bronchiectatic changes with adjacent plate atelectasis at the medial segment of right middle lobe and superior segment of right lower lobe.
  • Plate atelectatic changes in the inferior lingular segment.
  • No pleural effusion bilaterally.


Bronchiectatic changes: Bronchiectasis is a long-term condition where the airways of the lungs become widened, leading to a build-up of excess mucus that can make the lungs more vulnerable to infection. The most common symptoms of bronchiectasis include:

  • a persistent cough that
  • usually brings up phlegm (sputum)
  • shortness of breath.

Atelectatic changes. Atelectasis is a complete or partial collapse of the entire lung or area (lobe) of the lung. It occurs when the tiny air sacs (alveoli) within the lung become deflated or possibly filled with alveolar fluid. It results in the failure of the lung to expand (inflate) completely. It is sometimes referred to as collapsed lung.Large areas of atelectasis may be life threatening.The collapsed lung usually reinflates slowly if the airway blockage has been removed. But scarring or damage may remain.

The doctors suggested that Adek undergo chemotherapy, which she promptly rejected. And it was at this point that Adek called me to ask for help.

I subsequently prescribed her the following herbs:

  • A, C & D, M.
  • Herbal teas – Lung 1 + PLM and Lung 2 + SAP.

In addition to the herbs, Adek was told to take care of her diet. No sugar, no dairy  products, no fried food, no meat (or anything that walks!).

She followed my advice and declined any further medical treatment. Her doctor was not angry when Adek declined to undergo chemotherapy or radiotherapy. She told the doctor that she is taking our herbs..

(You look healthy and prettier! Thank you for your permission to use your photos without having to close your face!)

 Did the herbs help her? YES, very much and Adek is happy.

1. She felt she was much healthier than before she had cancer.

2. Due to the change of diet she has lost much weight – from 76 kg down to 60 kg. I told her she looked much prettier now!

3. Since taking the herbs, she did not have any problem – no more cough, no more phlegm and no more breathing difficulty.

4. She could live a normal life without pain, with good appetite, good sleep and able to travel visiting family members.

During her routine check-up with her doctor Adek was prescribed the following medications.

  • Wincardia – medication for prevention of heart attack which she did not take.
  • Pills for cholesterol which she also did not take.
  • Mecovit – vitamin B12, meant for vitamin B12 deficiency in people with anemia and nerve pain in hands.
  • Hovasc – medication to treat high blood pressure and cardiovascular diseases.


1. Skin cancer is rare in Malaysia. Skin cancers such as basal cell carcinoma, squamous cell carcinoma and melanoma are rare in this part of the world although they are the most common type of cancers in advanced, Western world.

In fact squamous cell carcinoma that Adek had is the first case that I ever encountered. In my 27 years of helping cancer patients, I have only encountered 3 patients with melanoma. Although my experience is limited, I learned from my experience that herbal therapy is effective and helpful for patients with skin cancer.

From the medical literature we know that squamous cell carcinoma (SCC) and basal cell carcinoma (BCC) are not as dangerous as melanoma. When surgically removed the cure rate for SCC and BCC is about 95%.

However, relapse of SCC is rather common, with the cumulative relapse rate of about 29% within 1-year of treatment.

It is also reported that about 2% of  SCC will eventually spread to other parts of the body, such as the lung (21%), bone (18%), central nervous system (6%) and liver (4%). Distant metastasis is of course associated with a poor prognosis.

2. Live to fight with your cancer? Adek is now 76 years old. She underwent a 2-hour surgery which helped her. The procedure did not carry much risk. To me, she did the right thing by agreeing to the surgical removal of the cancerous lump on her eyebrow.

Unfortunately a year later, CT scan showed the cancer had spread to her lungs. This commonly happen to most patients. The only option that doctors can offer her  is radiotherapy and/or chemotherapy. In more crude words – this is to declare war on her cancer. Fight the cancer cells to the end with toxic drugs and radiation. Adek refused these modalities  which I believe many people would think is a foolish decision – not to fight and kill the cancer cells.

I posed these questions to Adek.

  • Are you willing to undergo radiotherapy which is directed at your eyebrow? My guess is that you could or might be rendered blind because of the radiation. Are prepared to accept that outcome? Her answer was NO.

I have seen patients who underwent surgery for their brain cancer. This was followed by radiotherapy. They ended up totally blind after the treatment.

  • Adek had seen what chemo did to cancer patients. No, she was not willing to accept the side effects. At her age of 76, what would chemotherapy do to her quality of life?  It is hard to guess but it is surely not going to be like a nice walk in the park. Take a pause and reflect on the following quotations:

3. Learn to live with your cancer! You like war? In this part of the world, we Asians don’t like war.  Look at what happened to Vietnam, Iraq and now Ukraine. The ordinary folks suffered miserably and you see destruction everywhere! The only people who are happy are the manufactures of weapons!

Since the past 27 years, at CA Care, we teach our patients to learn how to live with their cancer. Let us not fight but let us take a holistic approach to heal our cancer.  This is what we did in the case of Adek.

1. Let us face reality that all of us will have to die one day. So death is not something we should fear. But what is most important is when we are still alive, let us live a happy life free of sufferings. Don’t suffer because of the treatments and then die! That is meaningless.

2. Know your inner feelings. If you wish to follow the “alternative path” of healing, you must believe in what you are going to do and be fully committed to that path. There is no half measure here.

3. Take care of your diet. Eat healthy and rightly.

4. Lead a stress-free life. Change your mental attitude and your old lifestyle.

5. Seek the help of Spirituality. Pray.

6. Take herbal teas to help the body restore the harmony within and heal itself.

It has been more than a year now and Adek is doing fine. Every day she is able to move around or travel without problem. There is no pain. She is not breathless. She eats and sleeps well. She does not suffer any side effects from taking the herbs every day. So to Adek, life is good. 

What else do you want?

Let me end by sharing one case of melanoma (which is more serious) which I encountered many years ago.

Guat was a 53 year-old-lady. In October 2007, she was diagnosed with skin cancer that had spread to her lungs. The doctor told Guat this was a serious disease and in my15 years of experience, this is the only case that I have seen.  Guat had fiery feeling in her chest almost every day. She had headache and was unable to sleep. She felt breathless when walking.

The doctor suggested that she start treatment with radiation immediately. Without radiotherapy the cancer might spread to her brain. Guat refused radiotherapy and came to seek our help on 2 November 2007. She was started on our therapy.

Note: According to medical literature, the 5-year survival for this type of cancer is 2% to 3%. With lung metastasis, medial survival is 11 months.

After One Year On Our Therapy

Chris: It has been more than a year since you first came.

Guat:  It is about one year now. There was always this fear. Do I need to go and have a scan?

C: No, there is no need to. What is the point? If the tumour were smaller, you would still need to continue taking the herbs. If it were bigger, what do you want to do? Still continue taking the herbs. The important thing is this. How do you feel now compared to one year ago when you came to see me?

G: Better.

Five Years Later: 9 August 2013

Guat: More than 5 years now. I am doing fine. My friends were asking why I don’t die yet!

Ten Years Later: December 2017                                                                                        (https://cancercaremalaysia.com/2017/12/18/one-glorious-morning-our-stage-4th-melanoma-lung-cancer-is-still-doing-fine/)

A gentleman walked into our centre one morning in December 2017. I could not recognise him. He reminded me that he is Guat’s husband. He told me Guat is doing fine. The last time I met Guat was 4 years ago –  in August 2013. After that Guat was out of our radar, not until this morning when her husband suddenly appeared!

Chris: How many years already?

Husband: Since, 2007. Already 10 years.

C: Aiyo, you are very lucky – very lucky, ha, ha.

PSA Dropped from 7,292 to 26 Within Two Months – Unbelievable but true!

This is a follow-up of an earlier article Eight & A Half Days In A Private Hospital Cost RM47,159.70 – worth it?

This story is about 73-year-old Johnny who had prostate cancer that had spread extensively to this bones. There is indication that the cancer has also spread to his lungs. Johnny  was admitted into a private hospital for treatment.  Unfortunately, nothing much came out of this “hospital adventure”. The family decided to give up further medical treatment and came to seek our help.

Johnny  was unable to walk on his own and had to use a wheelchair. He presented with severe pain due to the wide spread metastasis to his bones. His stomach was “gassy” and uncomfortable. He urinated about 7 to 8 times per night. This made his life really miserable.

Johnny was prescribed herbal teas to take care of his prostate, bone and lungs. In addition he was given Pain tea for his pain, Gastrovit for his gassy stomach and A-Kid-6 for his frequent urination.

Within a week, Johnny’s condition improved. However, what is most amazing  is that his PSA level came tumbling down from 7,292.00 to 26.08 as shown below.

It was indeed a great surprise when I got this whatsapp message on 25Nov 2022 from Johnny’s daughter.

In addition to the drop of his PSA, there is also an improvement of his Platelet Count – from 502 it came down to 300. Take note that an elevated platelet count is associated with an increased incidence of cancer and poor survival for many cancer types.

Johnny’s alkaline phosphatase (ALP) has also decreased from 208 to 165. ALP is associated with bony metastasis. An  elevated ALP is a prognostic marker for poorer survival in metastatic cancer.

Johnny started to take the herbs on 10 October 2022.  So from the blood results – PSA, platelet and ALP – he seemed to have improved after taking the herbs for just 5 weeks.

Johnny’s daughter wrote further:

Daughter: Actually the hospital kept calling for the next appointment but we rejected it. Then in between they still called till the last few days – they asked us do blood test and continue with hormone medication.

My husband just accepted the appointment to do PSA test but rejected others.

 After about 3 hours, the results were out. So we had to go back and see the same doctor who treated him the first time.

The doctor was so surprised with the results and thought it was his medicine that gave this good results.

 But my husband told the doctor: Actually we did not consume your medicine. We took herbs . The Dr was surprised and he respected our decision to continue taking the herbs. Then he asked us to take bone strengthening medication but we refused.

Chris: More important — very important. How is your dad’s condition now: 

a) His urination at night — how many times — before 7-8 times each nigh. 

b) His pain more or less after taking Pain tea? 

c) His movement — any improvement?

D: My dad’s condition is much, much better. He can walk with walker further than before he was started on the herbs. His pain was reduced – can say like no pain. His urination had improved, once or twice only at night.

This visit to the doctor to do the blood test costs RM233.00.

For your information, a similar test done in a private laboratory would cost only RM71, a third of the hospital cost!


1. This story is unbelievable but true.When I met Johnny, his daughter and son-in-law, I did not expect that we would get such a good response so soon, although deep down I felt the herbs would be able to help him. This is because we have helped many patients with prostate cancer and got good results.

In February 2013, I have posted a similar case, Prostate-Bone Cancer– Part 1: PSA Came Tumbling Down: From 6,963 to 200 and Severe Pains Vanished. This is the story of a 72-year-old man from Surabaya, Indonesia. His prostate cancer had spread extensively to his back bone. I have the opportunity to meet with this patient in his house when we visited Surabaya. He benefited from our herbs. You can listen to him in the videos.

2. In addition to the herbs for prostate cancer, we also know that our Pain Tea, A-Kid-6 tea and Gastrovit are effective and have helped many patients.

  • Pain Tea is taken 3 to 6 times a day. Generally the pain will go away rather “miraculously” and when the pain is gone, there is no need to take the pain tea anymore. Be rest assured that our pain tea does not contain any narcotic or opioid! It is also not a painkiller like the medications you get from the doctors. I formulated this pain tea some 20 years ago based on the Chinese TCM philosophy: “If there is free flow, there is no pain; If there is no free flow, there is pain.” Since then our pain tea has helped hundreds of patients with their pain.
  • Our A-Kid-6 tea was formulated to help people with frequent urination at night. Many people reported that their problem was resolved after taking the tea for a few days! I recalled one American man who came to us and was troubled with this problem that he would try not to go to sleep at night. After taking this tea his problem was resolved. He told me if I were to come to California and make this tea available there, I would make a lot of money!
  • Gastrovit tea is for gastric problems. Many people tell us it works like “magic”.

3. When Johnny was down with cancer, the family’s first priority was to seek medical help. Johnny was sent to a  well-known hospital in Kuala Lumpur for treatment. We respected that decision. Go ahead and see what the doctor can offer you!

For eight and a half days in the hospital the medical bills came to RM47,159.70. What did Johnny get out of that? What if his stay was extended to about a month or more – the hospital bills could easily reach RM200,000? Financial toxicity – this iswhat it means when writers write about the cost of cancer treatment!

I was surprised when Johnny’s family decided to seek our help and also decided to give up medical treatment.

The herbs and the change of diet helped him tremendously, to the point that it is unbelievable. But it is true. After the doctor saw the PSA dropped to 26 from 7,292 (within 2 months),  he was happy believing that it was his prescribed Cassodex and Duodart that did the job. The truth is, Johnny did not take the prescribed medicine! He took herbs.

It was good that the doctor was not angry for not following his instruction. Perhaps he could not dispute what he saw and heard that day – the so called unproven, unscientific herbs were effective for Johnny’s cancer.

For your information, the cost of  the herbs which Johnny took for 5 weeks cost less than RM2,000. Compare this to 8.5 days in the hospital which cost RM47,159.70. Of course, many people in the world would not want to know this truth. This would mean professional suicide.

But you, the patient, has a choice. Choose wisely!

Part 2: The Impact of High Cancer Cost on Patient & Family

George T and M. S.Baliga in their paper Generic Anticancer Drugs of the Jan Aushadhi Scheme in India and Their Branded Counterparts: The First Cost Comparison Study. Cureus 13 (11): e19231 (doi:10.7759/cureus.19231) wrote:

  • The costs of cancer drugs are exorbitant and cause significant financial toxicity  to the affected patient and their family members.
  • Considering this, Jan Aushadhi pharmacy stores were established across the country by the government of India with the objective of providing cheap generic medicines to patients.

Indeed it is laudable for the Indian government to take such concrete steps to help the ordinary poor folks of the country.

In an article Unaffordable treatment (https://www.dandc.eu/en/article/people-developing-countries-most-cancer-drugs-are-unaffordable) Max Klein and Jörg Schaaber wrote:

  • According to the World Health Organization, medication for a woman with breast cancer costs $ 18,500 a year in India and $ 33,900 in South Africa. In both countries, that amounts to about ten times the average annual income.
  • Though prices are higher in the USA, treatment there only costs 1.7 times more than the average annual income.
  • In Ethiopia, the most widespread form of cancer is breast cancer. It is a death sentence for most of the affected women: about two-thirds die. In Germany, by contrast, two-thirds survive.
  • About half of Tanzania’s people live below the international poverty line of $ 1.90 a day. Sometimes, a cancer drug is even more expensive in poor African countries than in Germany.
  • In high-income countries, over 80 % of children with cancer survive for more than five years, in poorer countries their share is below 30 %.

Van Minh Hoang et al (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5585616/) analyzed the household financial burden and poverty impacts of cancer treatment in Vietnam. They wrote:

  • As the costs of treatment for cancer are usually substantial, many households and individuals with cancer are facing financial catastrophes or are even pushed into poverty because of the costs.

Wenqi Fu and many fellow researchers  (https://bmjopen.bmj.com/content/11/6/e044322) studied the Effects of cancer treatment on household impoverishment in China. They wrote:

  • The financial burden of cancer treatment imposes a significant risk of household impoverishment despite wide coverage of social health insurance in China.

Alifah Zainuddin in an article The Real Cost Of Cancer In Malaysia (https://codeblue.galencentre.org/2022/06/03/the-real-cost-of-cancer-in-malaysia/) wrote:

  • The cost of treatment is also increasing … denying access to treatment to the very people who need them.
  • The estimated cost to treat cancer in Malaysia can go up to as high as RM395,000, though prices may vary based on the type of cancer, with different private hospitals charging different rates.
  • Example: For patient living with metastatic or advanced breast cancer:
  • Targeted therapy drug costs over RM6,000 per month for each cycle.
  • Chemotherapy drug costs more than RM5,500 every three weeks.
  • PET scan –  RM3,000 per scan.

In a paper Financial toxicity in Indonesian cancer patients & survivors: How it affects risk attitude

Stevanus Pangestu & Erwin Bramana Karnadi (https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/2331205X.2018.1525887) wrote: 

  • In Indonesia, cancer accounted for 13% of mortality in 2014.
  • Financial toxicity is a term used to describe the harmful financial burden faced by patients receiving cancer treatment.
  • The costs of cancer treatment in Indonesia remain high, and this circumstance may lead to financial toxicity. Health insurance does not eliminate financial distress among patients with cancer.
  • There should always be a proper physician-patient communication regarding the costs and affordability of cancer care.

In a paper Catastrophic health expenditure and 12-month mortality associated with cancer in Southeast Asia: results from a longitudinal study in eight countries published in MBC Medicine (https://bmcmedicine.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12916-015-0433-1) the authors wrote:

  • The Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) region consists of ten countries – Brunei, Cambodia, Indonesia, Laos, Malaysia, Myanmar, the Philippines, Singapore, Thailand, and Vietnam – and is home to over half a billion people.
  • The burden of cancer is increasing in the ASEAN region, due to population ageing and growth and the adoption of cancer-associated lifestyle behaviours.
  • Survival rates for most cancers are poor and quality of life is greatly impaired.
  • Cancer can have a profound economic effect on individuals and their households, especially among the poor and under-insured.
  • A cancer diagnosis in Southeast Asia is potentially disastrous, with over 75 % of patients experiencing death or financial catastrophe within one year.

ASEAN Costs in Oncology study (https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/2331205X.2018.1525887) discovered that:

  • 12 months after the (cancer) diagnosis, 29% of the patients had died and 48% experienced financial catastrophe.
  • The society has to be educated about the importance of  accomplishing financial security and
  • leading a healthy lifestyle.
  • As always, prevention is better than cure.

Cancer Situation In The United States Of American  – The Richest And Most Advanced Country.

Lastly, let us have a look at what the situation is in the United States – supposedly the most advanced and richest country in the world.

Part1: High Cost of Cancer Treatment

Part 2: The Impact of High Cancer Cost on Patient & Family

When a person is diagnosed with cancer, his/her world is often turned upside down. A cancer diagnosis impacts the patient in various ways:

  • Physically – pain, suffering, unable to walk etc.
  • Emotionally – how much time do I have? I cannot afford to die yet, my children are still small.
  • Financially – generally no one talks about this and the family suffers in silence.

The financial toll of cancer is seldom publicly discussed although it is a very important issue indeed. Is this subject a taboo in our Asian culture?

But let us face reality. Why don’t we discuss this issue and try to understand how to mitigate the impact of this financial burden. So, in the coming weeks/months, I shall be presenting you with a series of articles on this subject.  

Let us examine how cancer impact us financially. There are 4 main costs involved:

1. Consultation and Diagnosis.

Realizing that something is not right, it is important that you go and consult a competent doctor and find out what is exactly wrong with you. So be prepared to pay the following costs:

a. Consultation fee.

b. Blood test.

c. Imaging procedures like ultrasound, mammogram, CT scan, PET scan.

d. Biopsy.

A patient who had breast cancer did the above diagnostic procedures in a private hospital in Penang. It cost her RM 10,817. Take note, this is before any treatment is done yet.

2. Treatment Costs – outpatient and/or hospital stay.

The gold standard of medical treatment for cancer is: Surgery, Radiation and Pharmacological therapy.

Some patients receive all the three treatment modalities, while others receive one or two types.  The cost to the patient vary depending on the type and extent of the treatment.

Some “advanced or modern” hospitals may offer other treatments such as:

  • stem cell transplant,
  • hyperthermia,
  • photodynamic therapy,
  • cryotherapy,
  • immunotherapy,
  • mini-invasive interventional therapy,
  • particle implantation or particle knife,
  • radiofrequency ablation (RFA),
  • photon knife therapy.

The cost of any one of these therapies varies. So it is good to find out your financial obligation. Take note that for treatment in a private hospitals, every item used costs money. Every service provided costs money. Nothing is for free in there. For example:

  • You pay for a cotton bud if that item is used.
  • You pay a fee for the chair you sit on while undergoing chemotherapy.
  • Each time the doctor comes into your room and say “hello”, he/she collects a profession fee.

A patient with prostate cancer was hospitalized for 8.5 days in a private hospital in Kuala Lumpur. The total hospital bills came to RM47,159. Just imagine what the bill would be like if the stay was extended to a month or more? A cool RM200K?

A breast cancer patient underwent a total mastectomy without reconstruction at a private hospital in Hong Kong. The total bill came to HK$257,298 or RM155,139.

So cancer treatment in a private hospital is not cheap!

Drugs for Cancer.

Medication is a very common part of cancer treatment.

  • chemotherapy drug,
  • targeted therapy drug,
  • immunotherapy drug,
  • hormone therapy  drug,  
  • other drugs for pain, anti-nausea and other complications.

Some of these drugs can be taken as pills while some others are administered intravenously (IV) in a doctor’s office, clinic or hospital.

Some drugs appear to be affordable to the ordinary folks but some others may cost a bomb. For example:

  • A lung cancer patient received 24 injections of Imfinzi – an immunotherapy drug. Each injection cost IDR 40 Million or RM12,000. The total cost of 24 injections means IDR 960 Million or RM 288,000. The treatment failed and he came to seek our help.
  • A breast cancer patient was told to receive 17 times of immunotherapy treatment after her surgery. Each treatment is going to cost her RM15,000 or a total of RM255,000. Her son said the family does not have that kind of money and gave up.

Generic Drugs from India.

One aspect on cost of chemo drugs that many of us may not know is that, we are lucky and need to grateful to have India and Bangladesh to supply generic chemo drugs for the world. Without these generic drugs the cost of chemotherapy would have shot up sky high!

What are generic drugs? The US-FDA said:

  • A generic drug is a medication created to be the same as an already marketed brand-name drug in dosage form, safety, strength, route of administration, quality, performance characteristics, and intended use.
  • A generic medicine works in the same way and provides the same clinical benefit as the brand-name medicine. In other words, you can take a generic medicine as an equal substitute for its brand-name counterpart.

According to the Pharma Intelligence Center, as of 26 February 2021, there are currently 1,351 generic drugs available in India for the treatment of various cancers.

According to the US-FDA, generic medications can cost, on average, 80 to 85% less than the brand-name equivalents.  That is a great saving indeed and would help the poor folks of the developing countries. Thank you India!

According to the website  (https://www.clinicspots.com/cost/cancer-surgery/india):

  • The average cost of chemotherapy in India is INR Rs. 18,000 per session. This is equivalent to RM1,030.
  • The maximum charge for chemotherapy in India is about INR Rs. 50,000. This is equivalent to RM2,862.
  • The total costs of chemotherapy vary between INR 138,974 and INR 208,462. This is RM 7,954 and RM11,931.

A lung cancer patient had chemotherapy in one cancer hospital in Penang. The drugs used were:

  • Krabeva – a generic form of Avastin
  • 5-FU, and
  • Irinotecan – a generic by Intas.

He paid (as of August 2022) RM6,738 per cycle. Compare this to the costs in India!

3. Non-medical Cost. Besides the cost of treatment and hospital stay, there are some “invisible” costs such as:

  1. Transportation and travel costs. Although the cost of transportation may seem trivial compared to treatment, these expenses can add up quickly, especially if you seek treatment away from your hometown. These costs could include gas, tolls, parking, taxis, bus, train, or airplane fares, besides cost of hotel / apartment and food while away from home.
  • Lost wages or income. Some patients must stop working temporarily or permanently, or reduce their work schedules. All these can have serious financial repercussions.

4. Survivorship Care Costs.

We need to know that even when a patient has completed his/her  surgery, radiation and/ or chemotherapy, the costs of care do not end immediately.

Many cancer survivors may have to deal with certain cancer symptoms and the side effects of treatment. That can last for months to years after finishing the treatment – sometimes for the rest of their lives.

The costs may involve:

  • Visit to the doctor for regular check-up.
  • Some patients may suffer various side-effects, such as fatigue, difficulty in movement or many other symptoms and may need assistance such as:
  • supportive or palliative care,
  • rehabilitative therapy,
  • mental health services,
  • nutrition counseling, and
  • cardiology consultations as a result of their cancer or treatments.
  • Some patients may need to pay for helpers to care for themselves or for their children while at home.

Cost of Chemotherapy For Colon-Lung Cancer in Penang

Harry underwent surgery of his Stage 3B colon cancer in Hospital A in Penang. However, after the surgery he underwent 8 cycles of chemotherapy in Hospital B, also in Penang . Harry handed me his the medical bills for two cycles of chemotherapy that he received.

1.The chemo done on 20 January 2022 costs RM 6,624.50

2. The chemo done on 16 February 2022 costs RM 9,856.30

Based on the above, the average cost of a cycle of chemo is RM8,240.40. So we can guess that Harry had to spend a total of RM65,923 for the 8 cycles of chemotherapy to treat his colon cancer.

Unfortunately, the cancer did not go away. Six months after the completion of his chemo treatment, the cancer recurred in his lung. Harry was told to undergo more chemo. This second round of chemo is estimated to cost him RM66,000. Harry refused the treatment.

Let us try to understand what makes chemotherapy such an expensive treatment and why this is being promoted everywhere as the only “proven” treatment modality.

The itemized costs of chemotherapy are as below:

There are many things we can learn from the above table.

1. By wanting to “kill” the cancer, we need medicine to repair the damaged body as well.

There are 3 types of chemo drugs used for treating Harry’s cancer.

  1. Eloxatin or oxaliplain.  This cost RM 1,653 per cycle.
  2. TS-1 (Tegafur + Gimeracil + Oteracil). This cost 1,390 per cycle.
  3. Raltitrexed (Tomudex). This cost RM 4,140.

Since chemo drugs can cause damage to the body, patients are give drugs that can help “repair” that damage. These are not cancer drugs.

  1. Netupitant  and palonosetron. This drug in capsule is to be taken by mouth about 1 hour before the start of chemotherapy with or without food. This drug is a combination of netupitant and palonosetron and  is used to prevent nausea and vomiting caused by cancer chemotherapy. This cost RM 630.60 per cycle.
  • Pegfilgrastim or Pelgraz. One common side effect of chemotherapy is neutropenia or low levels of neutrophils (a type of white blood cell). Pelgraz is used to help fight infection following chemotherapy.  This cost  RM 1,210 per cycle.

Other non-cancer drugs administered to Harry were:

  • Chlorpheniramine. This is a antihistamine used to relieve symptoms of allergy, hay fever and the common cold. These symptoms include rash, watery eyes, nose, throat, skin, cough, runny nose and sneezing.
  • Dexamethasone. This is a corticosteroid and is used to treat many different inflammatory conditions such as allergic disorders and skin conditions.
  • Dextrose injection. This is used for nutrition support to treat low blood sugar and to decrease high potassium levels in the blood.
  • Diphenoxylate and atropine. This combination of drugs is used to treat severe diarrhea.
  • Esomeprazole or Nexium. This drug reduces the amount of acid your stomach makes. It’s widely used to treat indigestion, heartburn and acid reflux, and gastro-oesophageal reflux disease.
  • Granisetrom or Kytron. This drug is used to prevent nausea and vomiting caused by chemotherapy and radiotherapy.
  • Itopride or Ganatron. This drug is used  to treat symptoms of functional dyspepsia, i.e. patients having difficulties digesting food. Patients feel full after eating; they have bloating and have stomach pain.
  • Loperamide or Lomodium. This is a drug to treat diarrhoea or runny poo.
  • Pantoprazole.  This drug is used to treat heartburn, acid reflux and gastro-oesophageal reflux. It is also taken to prevent and treat stomach ulcers.

Just ask yourself. Before going into the hospital for chemotherapy, do you have the above 11 conditions that need medication? If no, why do you need them when undergoing chemotherapy?

2. You help me, I help you! That makes everybody happy. Then the project will have the full support of all interested parties.

For each cycle of chemo delivered to a patient the doctor earned about 7.5% to 11.4% of the total cost of the treatment. The more chemo he/she gives to patients the money more he/she earns. Good – the oncologist is well rewarded and should be happy.

On the other hand about 88% to 92% of the treatment cost goes to the hospital. So all parties should be happy.

Total cost of chemo treatmentHospital’s  earningDoctor’s earning
Jan. chemo – RM 6,524.505,779.50 (88.5%)745.00 (11.4%)
Feb. chemo – RM 9,856.309,111.30 (92.4%)745.00 (7.5%)

From the gross earning, the hospital needs to spend on cost of equipment, laboratory charges, room charges for treatment, nursing care , medical supplies and cost of drugs.

Other parties that are happy when you undergo chemotherapy are the companies that make the drugs and medical supplies. They too have a share of the pie.

Hospital charges of each chemo treatmentCost of chemo drugCost damage control drugsCost of other drugs and medical supplies
Jan. chemo – RM 5,779.503,043 (52.6%)102.70 (1.7%)193.00 (3.3%)
Feb. chemo – RM 9,111.305,793 (63.6%)666.50 (11.4%)211.00  (2.3%)

3. Nothing is for free in the private hospital.

For everything that is used in your treatment, know that you need to pay for it. There is no free lunch, except the natural air that your breathe in! Yes, if you need oxygen while in the hospital, you have to pay for it.

In one institution, I learned that you need to pay for the chair that you sit on while undergoing chemotherapy.

A careful look at the medical bills, you will know that the alcohol swab, gloves, face mask, gown, plaster, etc. used during your treatment have to be paid for too.

There is one item that attracted my attention which I was not sure what it means –  Cytotoxic/Chemo Reconstitution. A check in the internet gives this explanation.

  • A process in preparing a ready-to-use form of chemotherapy agent for the patient.
  • Some drugs must be stored in powdered form because they rapidly lose their power once they are mixed into a solution. These drugs will then have to be reconstituted, or mixed with a liquid or diluent, before they can be administered.
  • Before starting reconstitution, ensure that SOPs are adhered to – Hand-washing – Gloving – Gowning – Reconstituting – Disposal of waste products.

For each chemo treatment a patient pays RM 95.00 for this process. So nothing is for free!

Let me come to the last point. Everyone involved in chemotherapy are happy! The oncologist earns good income.  The hospital has a good share of the pie too (88% to 92%). Of course, the drug companies make good profit from the chemo treatment (52% to 63% of hospital’s earning). The important party that is not asked or forgotten, is the patient! Was Harry happy after receiving 8 cycles of chemotherapy? His metastatic lung cancer came back after six months. Do you think he was happy?

Stage 3B Colon Cancer Spread To Lung After Surgery. Chemo Failed.

Harry (not his real name) felt breathless sometime in May 2021. An examination by the doctor in a private hospital indicated three of the heart blood vessels were blocked. In June 2021, Harry underwent coronary angioplasty – i.e., a procedure using a tiny balloon catheter that is inserted in a blocked blood vessel to help widen it and improve blood flow to the heart.

While in the hospital Harry also suffered altered bowel habits and rectal bleeding. A colonoscopy was done and showed transverse colon (hepatic flexture) tumour and hemorrhoid.

Harry underwent a right hemicolectomy and omentectomy on 28 June 2022.

The histology report confirmed:

  • mucinous adenocarcinoma of colon with tubulo-villous adenoma at its edges.
  • Invasion of mesocolic fat, pT3 tumour.
  • Three of 8 lymph nodes are involved by metastatic tumour, pN1.
  • One microscopic focus of serrated  adenoma found at the tip of appendix.

Comment:  The  combination of mucinous adeonocarcinoma, tumour in the right colon and presence of serrated adenoma in the appendix is uncommon.

Stage 3B – T3N1M0

Harry was told to undergo chemotherapy in the same hospital where he had surgery. However, he was not happy with what he had gone through in that hospital and decided to take a break and ask around for various  opinions. Two months later, he decided to go for chemotherapy at  another hospital.

Before starting chemotherapy a PET scan was done. The PET scan report dated 9 September 2021 showed:

  • A focus tracer accumulation seen anterior to the third part of the duodenum (0.8 x 1.0 x 0.9 cm). This FDG avid lymph node likely represents metastasis.
  • Patchy ground glass opacity seen in the left lower lobe of the lung.
  • There is no evidence of metastasis to the brain, nodes,  neck, thorax, mediastinum, pelvis, thyroid, lung, stomach, liver, pancreas, spleen, adrenals and bones.

Harry underwent 8 cycles of chemotherapy.

He did not suffer any severe side effect except a little numbness of his hands.

The chemo treatments was completed in April 2020. A PET scan done on 7 April 2022 indicated:

  • Comparing with the scan done on 9 September 2021, the present scan indicate complete metabolic response to the treatment. Problem solved!
  • Patchy ground glass opacity seen in the left lower lobe of the lung is unchanged in appreance.
  • No evidence of FDG avid lesion seen in any other parts of the body.

Six months later, Harry did another PET scan. PET scan report dated 13 October 2022 showed:

  • Patchy ground glass/consolidative opacity seen  in the left lower lobe of the lung was grown larger.
  • New patchy nodular opacity seen in the anterior segment of the right upper lobe.

Harry was told to undergo another 8 cycles of chemotherapy using the regimen – TS 1, Irinotel + Avastin. The estimated cost of this second round of chemo would be about RM 66K as outlined  below (a note given to by the hospital).

Harry declined to undergo further chemotherapy.

Chris: Why did you not want to go for more chemotherapy?

Harry: I have done that before and it did not work!

C: When you did the first round of 8 cycles of chemo, did you ever ask the doctor if the treatment is going to cure you?

H: No. I did not know anything. I just followed what I was told to do.

C: In all, including  your heart operation, how much have you spent?

H: Roughly about RM200,000.


One big lesson we can learn from this case is that surgery and chemo did not cure Harry’s Stage 3B colon cancer.

After the completion of chemotherapy, Harry had a PET scan which showed everything was clear – no more cancer! So the treatment was effective. But that was just a …. (put in any word you like)!

About 6 months later, another PET scan showed that the cancer had recurred. Harry was asked to do more chemo.

Ask these questions:

1. What is the use of doing a PET scan when the result is so short-lived. A “success” had turned into a “disappointment” within 6 months.

2. Harry was asked to go for another round of 8 cycles of chemo which is going to cost him another RM 66K at least. Is that going to be a good investment for him?

Eight & A Half Days In A Private Hospital Cost RM47,159.70 – worth it?

Johnny (not his real name) is 73 years old. This is his story.

February 2020.  His problem started with frequent (7 to 8 times) urination at night.  There was no blockage of urine flow. Then he had backache. He did nothing about the problem.

Vaccination history.

  • Sinovac, first dose in August 2021. He felt weak after the vaccination.
  • Sinovac, second dose in September 2021. Felt cold in the stomach and later had bloated stomach.

Admission to Hospital B in Kuala Lumpur.

Johnny  was eventually admitted into a private Hospital B in Kuala Lumpur on 19 September 2022. During the 8.5 days in the hospital he received the  following:

1. Blood test.

 19 September 202224 September 2022
Platelets502   (High)534   (H)
Alkaline phosphatase208   (High)190   (H)
PSA7,652  (High)7,292 (H)

2. PET scan – 20 September 2022.

There is a FDG-avid lesion at the left prostate lobe measuring 1.8 x 2.2 cm.

There are multiple small lung nodules scattered in both lungs,

largest measuring up  to 0.8 x 0.7 cm at the right lung base.

There are multiple FDG-avid bone lesions along: bilateral humeri, bilateral scapulae, bilateral clavicles, manubrium-sternum, multiple bilateral ribs, along the spine, pelvic bones (bilateral ilium, pubic bones) and along bilateral femur.

Some of the bone metastases have extraosseous soft-tissue components, particularly at thoracic vertebrae (T7, T8 and T 11 vertebrae) and left ilium.


1. Lesion at left prostate lobe likely corresponding to primary prostate carcinoma.

2. Multiple bilateral lung nodules – suspicious for lung metastases.

3. Multiple bone metastases.


While in the hospital, Johnny  received oral chemotherapy and five times of radiation treatment.

The Total Medical Bill

Let us look at the medical bills critically.

1. Doctor Charges

Of the RM47,150.70 paid, about 25% (RM11,880) goes to the doctor.

  • Doctor made 15 visits.

The first visit was RM230.

Subsequent 12 visits cost RM100 per visit.

Two other visits cost RM150 per visit.               

  • Johnny had 2 short infusion and this cost RM500 per infusion.
  • Johnny had 5 radiation treatment (VMAT). This cost RM9,150.

2.  Hospital Charges

The total hospital charges is RM35,279.70 and represents about 75% of the total cost of treatment.

1. Administration charges  $45

2. Chemo drug

  • CASODEX, 500 mg tablet, 26 tablets taken while in the hospital, and
  • 26 tablets on discharge. RM 980 x 2 = RM 1,960.

3. Equipment charges  RM395.00

4. General medical supplies RM 554.10

5. Imaging procedures

  • CT scan RM1,350
  • CT/PET scan package RM3,800

6. Laboratory  RM 802

7. Medical record RM18.00

8. Miscellaneous RM 110.00

9. Pharmacy  –  total cost RM5,667.10.

The drugs prescribed while in the hospital consist of antibiotic;  steroid (dexamethasone) – for swelling and inflammation;  nexium for gastrooesophageal reflux; senokot for costipation and Duodart.

Duodart cost RM132 while in the hospital and RM356.40 upon discharge (to bring home). Here is what it is used for (info from the internet):  benign prostatic hyperplasia (BPH).

10. Room charge for 8.5 days amount to RM1,360 (two-bedded at RM160 per day).

11. Treatment and Procedure Services – RM 19,818.50. This include:

  • nursing services,
  • injection charges,
  • medical consumables,
  • vac lock (RT) RM600.00 (Cushion create a rigid and secure support around the patient during radiotherapy).
  • VMAT (radiotherapy) planning RM11,550.00
  • VMAT treatments RM6,300

Lessons We Can Learn From This Case

1. Can the treatment be done on outpatient basis? Was he adequately treated while in the hospital?  Johnny needs to treat his prostate cancer that had spread to the bones. From the information in the medical bills above, do you think he was adequately treated? Do you think he really needs to be admitted into the hospital just to receive 5 times radiation and swallow some cancer pills? Could these treatment  be done or taken on an outpatient basis, to save cost?

During his 8.5 days in the hospital, Johnny received 5 radiation treatments. Then he was given Casodex. This is the medicine to treat prostate cancer. Then he was given Duodart. This is a drug to treat benign prostatic hyperplasia (BPH). But Johnny already had prostate cancer not BPH! Mind boggling indeed.

Even more mind boggling is, Johnny had extensive bones  metastases and many tiny nodules in the lungs. This is revealed by the PET/CT scan that he did. Did he not need treatment for his bones and lungs?  If that is the way it is, what is the whole idea of doing a PET scan? To just know if the cancer has spread and no treatment is needed?

2. Cancer treatment in the private hospital is not cheap! Johnny was treated in a private hospital for 8.5 days. This cost the family RM47,159.70. Many of us may want to ask – why so expensive?  Others may say it is already cheap because  there are many others who had to pay much more than that. 

Anyway, for the rich RM47K is just peanut but for those who are poor or in the middle income group, that sum is a big deal indeed. One week’s hospital treatment cost about RM50K. What would have happened if it was extended to a month’s stay? RM200K?  I know of many patients who had to spend that kind of money!

As I am writing this case, one patient told me he had colon cancer and underwent surgery and chemotherapy. He had already spent about RM200,000 ( I am not sure if this figure is corrrect or not. I did not see his medical bills). Many years ago, I knew of a medical doctor who spent about RM1.7 million for his wife’s cancer. In spite of that she died  in less than a year while on treatment.

3. What if you have no savings? If you have no money, there is no choice – go to the government hospital or the university hospital.  You may be able to receive similar treatments without having to pay through your nose!

4. Understand the reality. What could be the outcome after going to the expensive hospital? Can cure? Many people have the impression that expensive means better or the best!

I asked Johnny’s daughter. Can the treatment cure him?  She replied: According to the doctor there is a high chance of recovery, to lower his PSA. Wow, is that the answer you are looking for? Lower the PSA only?

For the bone metastasis this was what the doctor said: Can’t be helped. Just maintain and don’t let it get worse. Wonder how when no treatment was given!

Well, you can interpret what the doctor said anyway you like!

Johnny’s  PSA was 7,292 on 24 September 2022 (don’t be mistaken, it was 7.2 thousand plus not 7.2).  To be “free or cured” of  prostate cancer the PSA needs to come down to 6.50 ( yes, 6 point 5 for age 70 and above). When can that happen? Or can that ever happen?

5. Do you believe in alternative healling therapy?  Johnny’s wrote me before sending her father to the hospital for treatment. It was the family’s decision so. I did not give any comment. Go ahead and find out the truth for yourself!

I am aware that what we are doing is considered by most “educated” people as hocus pocus, not proven, not scientific, etc.  But let us see what happens now! Where can Johnny go after being discharged from the hosptial and after spending RM50K?  Go on spending more money chasing the cancer?

Johnny Came To Seek Our Help

When Johnny came to seek our help, he was on a wheelchair and was not able to walk  on his own (this is after being treated in the hospital).  

He was prescribed the following herbal teas for his:

  • prostate cancer
  • bone cancer and
  • lung cancer.

. In addition he was given herbs for his:

  • stomach gas and
  • frequent urination.

Let me reproduce the whatsapp messages between me and Johnny’s daughter as we monitored the progress of Johnny’s healing.

Chris: Your pa took the herbs? Any problem drinking them? Did he find any changes to his condition?

Daughter:  Ya, he followed everything . He said the taste of the herbs is bad but he can take it. He feels fine so far. He told me he has less pain.  Only if going to lie down can feel a bit pain. So far others ok.

C: Your dad had taken the herbs for about one month already.  How is he progressing? Any improvement?

D:  I noticed he is doing well with your herbs. Ya, much better. Many thanks. During sleep pain only on the right side of  his back. When sitting no pain.  I noticed his leg feel stronger than before.

C: Still cannot walk?

D: This morning he tries to walk using the walker … around 15 steps, he felt legs were weak.

C: You need to keep trying because if you don’t use the legs, then you cannot use them anymore after too long.

D: We are just scared he falls unless we are there to help him. Will take your advice and let him keep trying .

C: Two more questions . Gastrovit — for his stomach gas — did he take it and did he get better?

D: That day he took but now no more pain, so he takes only when needed.

C:  I gave A-Kid-6 for his frequent urination (before he urinated 7 – 8 times at night), now what happen?

D:  Ya, already reduced to 3 to 4 times at night.

D: The other day, the hospital called to go for his appointment, but we rejected the appointment.

C: Your dad does not want to go to hospital again? Why?

D: He said, because he is already taking your herbs and feels better. So just concentrate on your treatment.

Up date: My Pa looks better. Leg stronger.

Think hard:

  • In the US they call herbal treatment as snake oil therapy! And people like me are labeled as snake oil peddler! You buy that?
  • 8.5 days in the hospital cost about RM47,150  and what do you get out of it?
  • One month of herbs cost only RM1,500  – which do you prefer?
  • Do you believe that cheap stuff does not work?
  • Was the treatment in the hospital just only for his prostate cancer? Ignoring the metastases in the bone and lungs?
  • Do you think by just taking Casodex his prostate cancer can be cured?
  • Make your own choice – wisely!

The Shockingly Hight Cost of Breast Cancer Treatment

Lian (not her real name) is a 65-year-old lady from one of the  Riau islands of Indonesia. I received an email from her son Henry (not real name):

  • My mother felt something in her breast. It was getting bigger from mid-2021.
  • This is about 2 months after she got vaccinated.
  • I brought her to Jakarta in October 2021 for a check-up. An ultrasound in Jakarta showed the diameter of the  tumour in her right breast is 2 cm.
  • Recently she felt pain and I brought her to Hospital A, a private hospital in Penang, last week to do another check-up.
  1. Blood tests.

Her full blood picture, liver function test and tumour markers were all within normal range.

  • USG.

Ultrasound Right Breast:

  • A solid lesion with irregular margins seen at about 6 o’clock position (above) measuring about 2.9 x 2.7 x 2.7 cm. This is suspicious of a malignancy.
  • There is a solid lobulated lesion measuring about 0.7 x 0.5 x 0.7 cm at about 2 o’clock position, about 1.8 cm from the nipple. this contains some calcifications.
  • An enlarged right axillary node measuring 1.9 x 1.2 x 1.8 cm shows loss of normal fatty hilum (above). A few other smaller right axillary nodes also show loss of normal fatty hilum.
  • Mammogram of right breast.
  • There is a distinct lump in her right breast.
  • PET scan.
  • No focal FDG-avid lesions in the head and neck region,  lung parenchyma lesions, chest wall lesions, mediastnal nodes or hilar masses.
  • An FDG-avid mass measuring 2.9 x 2.7 cm in the right breast.
  • An FDG-avid right axillary node measures 1.8 x 1.3 cm. Small nodes are seen around this. No other FDG-avid axillary nodes seen. 
  • Biopsy.
  • Right breast lump, core biopsy (6 o’clock): Invasive carcinoma of no special type (NST), grade 3.
  • The tumour cells are negative for oestrogen, progesterone and Her2 receptors.

Lian was told that due to the “big” size of the tumour, she had to undergo chemotherapy first before her surgery. The family was unhappy with the idea of undergoing chemo before surgery. So they decided to go home without any further treatment!

Costs Of Diagnostic Procedures

Henry said:

  • I spent around RM 10,817 in Hospital A. This costs include the following:
  • PET scan which is around RM 4,600.
  • RM 3,000 for mammogram, blood test and ultrasound.

Before and after the surgery Lian needs to undergo chemotherapy and immunotherapy.

  • For chemo, it is RM 5.000 each time and she must take 8 times, every 3 weeks. Total cost RM40,000.
  • For Immunotherapy, it is RM 15,000 each time and she needs to receive the treatment about 17 times for a year. Total RM255,000.
  • I was told that this is a triple negative cancer  – so must undergo  immunotherapy (antibody) besides chemotherapy to avoid the cancer’s return.
  • The cost for chemo + immunotherapy is very expensive. We couldn’t afford to do it.

Told About CA Care

Henry wrote:

  • When we were back home from Penang, my cousin told me about you. He heard from his friend named Pak Edy who suffered bowel cancer 12 years ago and he got treatment from you
  • And later, my sister also talked with our neighbour. Coincidentally, her mother is also taking your herbs. Her mother took your herbs since last year.

At this point I received an email from Henry.

Good evening, Doctor,

The biopsy indicated the cancer is a triple negative and it is a Stage 2 cancer.Hopefully you can give us some advice on what we must do to cure her disease.

The reason why we are trying to find other alternative is because we can’t afford to do the chemo and immunotherapy which is very expensive. If we need to see you in Penang, I will try to arrange the time to meet your schedule.

Reply:  Any woman who has breast cancer — had biopsy but refused to remove the whole breast is just STUPID — AMAT BODOH. You must remove the breast now. You cannot just keep it there. Do a total mastectomy i.e., remove the cancerous breast totally.

This is a triple negative cancer type — dangerous! After you remove the breast, come and see me after 2 weeks. I would not see people who do not remove their cancerous breast.

Hi Doctor,

Thank you for the quick response doctor. Do you have any recommendation for the hospital to do the mastectomy? Because if we go back to Hospital A, we would be asked to do chemo and immunotherapy first, then do surgery after that.

Reply: Okay, go to Dr. B in Hospital B and see what he has got to say.

Hi Doctor,

We took action very quickly after we got your advice. I tried searching for some hospitals which are reachable by sea and bus from our hometown.The first option is hospitals in JB. However, there is no breast cancer specialist in JB. Then I found in a breast cancer specialist in Hospital M in Melaka.  We did teleconsultation by video at the beginning. The doctor said that the tumour seems not so big from the report I sent to her.Therefore, she asked us to meet her in Melaka to see whether or not we can do the surgery without chemo first.

The first estimated cost for mastectomy in M Hospital RM 12,000. Since my mom also needs to remove another tumour in her left breast then the cost will come to around RM 15,000.

The estimated cost of surgery in Hospital A in Penang is RM 20,000. This is only the cost for surgery excluding room charges.

Again, thank you so much for your quick response. Really appreciate it.

Oct 19, 2022. Hi Doctor,  Good afternoon.

My mother has done the mastectomy yesterday Oct 19th without chemo in Melaka.

Oct 21, 2022. Hi Doctor,

My mom was discharged from hospital this afternoon and everything seems to be okay. Herewith I attached the hospital bill for your reference.

  1. Total hospital charges                                 RM10,039.71
  2. Doctors’ fees                                               RM  6,499.27
  3. Surgeon               RM3,988.00
  4. Anaesthesia               1,490.15
  5. Lab services                  477.12
  6. Radiology services      544.00

                              Total cost of mastectomy + lumpectomy RM 16,538.98

Lessons We Can Learn From This Case

  1. Get your bearing right. I am really glad that Lian took an immediate step to have the cancerous lumps removed from her breasts. If these lumps were allowed to grow in there, they will eventually burst and could give rise to more problems. Over the years, I have seen patients who came to me with “rotten” breasts. They have the mistaken idea that herbs or supplements can make the cancerous tumour in their breast go way. Wrong!
  • Chemo before surgery – different experts have different opinions! Lian was told to undergo chemotherapy before surgery. She refused chemo and went home rather “lost”, that is after spending RM 10,817 for the diagnostic procedures in Penang. My advice to her son was: Go and find another doctor! I am happy that she found one doctor in a Melaka Hospital to do the surgery without having to do chemo first. 
  • Before agreeing to the treatments, know what you are getting into. The standard protocol to treat breast cancer is: surgery, followed by chemotherapy and/or radiotherapy. But now, the latest option being offered to patients is immunotherapy which costs a “bomb”!

You may want to ask: How effective is immunotherapy?  This is answer that I got from the internet:


From the very beginning Lian and her son were given some idea of what the total cost of the treatment is going to be like. Surgery would come to about RM30,000, chemo RM40,000 and immunotherapy would cost her at least RM255,000 or a quarter million ringgit. The family could not afford that. This is indeed sad.

Over the years many patients who came to seek our help told me that they had to sell a house or a piece of land to pay their medical bills. I also had patients who spent RM30K and had no more money. They just packed off and went  home – giving up the idea of receiving medical treatment in Penang.

  • Ask if the treatments like chemo and/or immunotherapy are going to cure your cancer. Spending money is one thing, the most important question we need to ask is – what would be the outcome of the treatment after spending a quarter million ringgit? Is the cancer cured? Unfortunately, no one can guarantee a positive outcome. Unfortunately too, some patients would NOT want to know the answer to this all important question! Over the years, I have seen many failures  — money lost and patient ended up with severe side effects of the treatment.

Dr. Norah Lynn Henry wrote an article Immunotherapy for Breast Cancer Treatment: Is It an Option? (https://www.cancer.net/blog/2020-09/immunotherapy-breast-cancer-treatment-it-option). She said:

  • One challenge of immunotherapy is not knowing who is likely to benefit from the treatment.
  • Second, immunotherapy can cause substantial side effects, including life-threatening ones. The most common side effects are skin reactions, such as redness and blistering, and flu-like symptoms, such as fever, nausea, weakness, and body aches. Different types of immunotherapy can cause different side effects.
  • An important third challenge is the high cost of this treatment.
  • Beware, the cost of treatments differ from hospital to hospital. Lian went to Hospital A in Penang.  She had to spend RM 10,817 on diagnostic procedures! That is before the actual surgery which would cost another RM20,000 plus.

Just a few months ago, one patient had a total mastectomy at Hospital B in Penang. In total she spent only RM15,000. Take note, Hospital B is said to be a non-profit (privately funded) hospital. But be reassured the surgeon who did the mastectomy is just as competent and well known as others in Penang. In fact, this surgeon is one of the two doctors I would recommend that you go to if you have breast cancer. Remember again, expensive does not necessarily mean it is better!

  • Beware of the overuse of diagnostic procedures, overuse of PET scan, over treatment, etc. Take a close look at what Lian had to undergo in preparation of her surgery – she did a blood test, ultrasound, mammogram, PET scan and finally biopsy. All these procedures contributed significantly to the total cost of RM10K. Let me just pose one question – are ALL these procedures absolutely necessary? For some procedures the answer is yes, but not for all of them.  Let me not give my own opinion on this  but quote what other medical experts say …..

Shannon Brownlee et al in an article Evidence for Overuse of Medical Services Around the World (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5708862/) wrote:

  • We use the term overuse to refer to any services that are unnecessary in any way and for any reason.
  • Overuse (of medication, diagnostic tests, therapeutic procedures) is a global problem that afflicts rich and poor countries alike.
  • In the United States, estimates of spending on overuse … range from 6% to 8% of total health care spending.
  • Around the world, overuse of some individual services may be as high as 80% of cases.

Kelsey Chalmers et al (https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamanetworkopen/fullarticle/2779118) wrote:

  • Overuse is defined as the delivery of tests and procedures that provide little or no clinical benefit, are unlikely to have an impact on clinician decisions, increase health care spending without improving health outcomes, or risk patient harm in excess of potential benefits.
  • Although clinicians are responsible for ordering tests and treatments, their practice patterns may be influenced by hospital policies and culture.

A report by AACC – formerly known as the American Association for Clinical Chemistry (https://www.aacc.org/cln/cln-stat/2018/march/15/close-up-on-diagnostic-test-overuse) said:

  • Overuse of laboratory tests is a chronic problem.
  • Study finds up to 70% of lab tests in a hospital setting are likely either clinically unimportant or unnecessary.

In an article Understanding over-imaging (https://www.mdanderson.org/publications/conquest/understanding-over-imaging.h37-1589046.html) Laura Sussman wrote:

  • The American Society of Clinical Oncology (ASCO) recommended against the use of CT, positron emission tomography (PET), tumor markers and nuclear bone scans in early-stage breast cancers.
  • Carlos Barcenas, M.D., points out that the recommendations of the National Comprehensive Cancer Network — the gold standard for treatment guidelines — clearly state that for women with early disease, the proper procedures for diagnosis only include mammograms, ultrasounds, clinical exams and blood work.
  • “Often doctors think they’re not being good to their patients if they don’t do all they can by way of testing,” explains Giordano, chair of Health Services Research. “But there’s a shift in focus to doing what matters for the patient and what’s proven to improve outcomes, rather than testing for the sake of testing.”

Caroline Helwick in an article PET Scans Not Recommended for Most Patients with Breast Cancer: Potential New Controversy in Breast Cancer Testing (https://www.ahdbonline.com/issues/2010/march-april-2010-vol-3-no-2/93-article-93)  wrote:

  • According to the updated 2010 practice guidelines of the National Comprehensive Cancer Network (NCCN), the work-up of patients with early breast cancer should not include imaging by positron-emission tomography (PET) or by PET/computed tomography (CT) scanning.  The NCCN Breast Cancer Panel gave a thumbs down for the use of this modality in a number of settings.
  • PET or PET/CT can be helpful in some cases of stage III disease in which standard staging studies are equivocal or suspicious, but it should not be routine in the staging of newly diagnosed stage I, II, or operable stage III breast cancer, the Breast Cancer Panel concluded.
  • The implication of our recommendations is that PET/CT is overused in breast cancer,” said Robert Carlson, MD, of Stanford Cancer Center, Palo Alto, California.
  • “What is fueling the overuse? I don’t really know. It is simple to order, but it is very expensive. So there are financial issues in terms of rewards for physicians who perform them frequently.
  • Our society assumes that any technology with a high price tag has value, but the newest technology is not necessarily the best technology,” Dr Carlson said.